An Ongoing Family Legacy of Fierce Litigation Providing Guidance, Compassion & Aggressive Advocacy

Berg v. Nationwide

$21 Million Verdict

In an insurance bad faith action, arising from a $25,000 collision claim, Mayerson Law secured a punitive damage award of $18 million, plus $3 million in attorney fees. The verdict was entered in Berks County on June 21, 2014. This is the largest insurance bad faith verdict, by a policy holder against their own insurance company, in Pennsylvania history.

Why Choose Mayerson Injury Law?

  • We are not a big box law firm operating on volume, assigning cases to inexperienced lawyers
  • Record Breaking Results Dating Back to 1963
  • Largest Insurance Bad Faith Verdict in Pennsylvania History, Entered by a Trial Court Judge Sitting as the Fact Finder
  • We are Pottstown's preeminent personal injury law firm with over fifty 5-Star Google Reviews from real personal injury clients
  • We are a boutique law firm with decades of experience battling insurance company tactics
  • You Won't Pay Unless We Recover Compensation For You
  • If You Can't Travel, We Will Come to Your Home or Hospital
  • We Offer Free & Confidential Case Evaluations


The case began on September 4, 1996, when Sherri Berg was involved in a serious motor vehicle collision. A claim was submitted to her insurer, Nationwide Mutual. Nationwide recommended the Bergs have their collision claim appraised and repaired by one of its designated Blue Ribbon repair facilities, through its Blue Ribbon Repair Program. Nationwide promised a Blue Ribbon appraisal, from a Blue Ribbon repair facility, backed by a Blue Ribbon guarantee. Unbeknownst to the Bergs, the vehicle was originally appraised as a structural total loss due to a twisted frame. Instead of reporting the total loss to the Bergs, as required by state law, Nationwide directed the vehicle be transported to an undisclosed, unapproved repair facility to attempt the frame repairs that its Blue Ribbon facility was unable to undertake. Four months later the vehicle was returned to the Bergs in a dangerous condition, with hidden structural repair failures.

This firm proved that Nationwide was secretly aware of the dangerous structural repair failures per routine inspections it performed throughout the extended, four-month repair period. Nationwide nevertheless permitted the vehicle to be returned to the Bergs with hidden structural repair failures causing the tires to wear down to the metal belts. When the Bergs learned of the extensive, structural repair failures and retained legal representation, Nationwide implemented its well-documented strategy to price this firm out of the litigation by concealing evidence, asserting false claims of privilege, and misrepresenting the law to the trial court. After six years of appellate review this firm won a new trial during which it was proven that Nationwide paid its own attorneys in excess of $3 million to defend its fraudulent and deceitful handling of the underlying collision claim, in what can only be described as a reprehensible attempt to price this firm out of securing justice for the Bergs.

This case is now discussed across the legal community and other lawyers seek our advice in their legal battles on behalf of clients facing similar obstacles.

We are grateful to the legal system which prevailed, at each appellate level, so that our trial judge could render Justice after 16 years of intense litigation.

Mayerson Injury Law Wins!

We've Recovered Tens of Million on Behalf of Clients
  • Retired School Custodian $2,650,000
  • Injured Good Samaritan $1,965,000.00
  • Reckless Driver Car Accident $1,600,000.00
  • Head On Collision Case $1,150,000.00
  • Young Single Mother Permanently Disabled in Head-On Collision $1,150,000.00
  • Father of Three $1,130,000.00
  • Truck Driver $1,075,000.00
  • Underinsured Motorist Arbitration $1,025,000.00
  • Settlement for Head-On Collision $865,000.00
  • Driver with Prior Spine Surgery $750 Thousand

Request A Free Case Evaluation

We Accept Calls 24/7
  • Please enter your first name.
  • Please enter your last name.
  • Please enter your phone number.
    This isn't a valid phone number.
  • Please enter your email address.
    This isn't a valid email address.
  • Please make a selection.
  • Please enter a message.